[SECOND] [AMENDMENT] [BYLAW REVISION] Character Starting Experience Ranked Vote
Status message
Displaying output for ranked votingOpen Votes
I, Chase Jelliffe, as Assistant Head Coordinator 1, hereby propose the following change to Character Bylaw 3.b through a ranked vote:
This proposal requires a Second.
The choices are as follows with more detail below
Choice 1: 160 XP
Choice 2: 140 XP
Choice 3: 120 XP
Choice 4: 100 XP
Choice 5: 80 XP
Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change)
Abstain
Reasoning: There have been quite a lot of requests made to propose an increase to starting XP due to the fundraiser XP bump that occurred last year. For half of 2024, characters were able to be created at 160 XP instead of 60. There was positive feedback about being able to create characters with more depth and capability for OWbN’s current meta as well as complaints that now new players to the org can only start with 60xp when just a few months ago their friends started with 160. Rather than shoot for a random amount, I figured it would be best to put a range of values so chronicles can choose the value they are comfortable with. To note, the last time starting experience was changed was in 2013 where XP was changed from 30 to 60.
Current limitations on how these points are spent:
These points may be spent only as Experience Points, not as creation/bonus points. This spending should follow your Chronicle's House Rules
Any awards of traits, abilities, or other character statistics count towards this limit as the amount of experience that the player would have had to spend to purchase that particular statistic.
These points cannot be allowed to purchase any power above second Basic in any out of clan Disciplines.
Legacy: This bylaw is retroactive to characters created on January 1st, 2025 and after.
Bylaw 3.b Before:
b. A new player character is restricted to the points allowed under standard character creation rules in the appropriate Mind's Eye Theater book, plus up to sixty (60) experience points.
Choice 1: 160 XP
Bylaw 3.b After:
b. A new player character is restricted to the points allowed under standard character creation rules in the appropriate Mind's Eye Theater book, plus up to 160 experience points.
Choice 2: 140 XP
Bylaw 3.b After:
b. A new player character is restricted to the points allowed under standard character creation rules in the appropriate Mind's Eye Theater book, plus up to 140 experience points.
Choice 3: 120 XP
Bylaw 3.b After:
b. A new player character is restricted to the points allowed under standard character creation rules in the appropriate Mind's Eye Theater book, plus up to 120 experience points.
Choice 4: 100 XP
Bylaw 3.b After:
b. A new player character is restricted to the points allowed under standard character creation rules in the appropriate Mind's Eye Theater book, plus up to 100 experience points.
Choice 5: 80 XP
Bylaw 3.b After:
b. A new player character is restricted to the points allowed under standard character creation rules in the appropriate Mind's Eye Theater book, plus up to eighty (80) experience points.
Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change)
Bylaw 3.b remains unchanged.
Abstain
You choose not to have your vote counted after your preferences are exhausted.
Results (using Instant Run-Off):
- Choice 1: 160 XP (52.1%)
- Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change)
- Choice 4: 100 XP
- Choice 5: 80 XP
- Abstain
- Choice 3: 120 XP
- Choice 2: 140 XP
Rounds | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Choice 1: 160 XP | 36 | 36 | 36 | 36 | 38 |
Choice 2: 140 XP | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Choice 3: 120 XP | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Choice 4: 100 XP | 3 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 0 |
Choice 5: 80 XP | 3 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) | 30 | 30 | 30 | 32 | 35 |
Abstain | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Event log for this vote:
- Round 1: Option "Choice 2: 140 XP" had zero votes for 1st choice and therefore is eliminated.
- Round 1: Eliminated: Choice 3: 120 XP (votes reallocated: 1)
- Columbus, OH - USA, Columbus in Darkness's choice (Choice 3: 120 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 2: Option Choice 2: 140 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 2: Option Choice 3: 120 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 2: Eliminated: Abstain (votes reallocated: 1)
- AHC 1's choice (Abstain), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 3: Option Choice 2: 140 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 3: Option Choice 3: 120 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 3: Option Abstain not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 3: Eliminated: Choice 5: 80 XP (votes reallocated: 3)
- Fredericksburg, VA - USA, Caine's Chosen: Liberty in Death's choice (Choice 5: 80 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Norwalk, CT - USA, Rails of Revolution's choice (Choice 5: 80 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Phoenix, AZ - USA, Unchained Arizona's choice (Choice 5: 80 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Option Choice 2: 140 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Option Choice 3: 120 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Option Choice 5: 80 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Option Abstain not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Eliminated: Choice 4: 100 XP (votes reallocated: 5)
- Twin Cities, MN, - USA, The Last Stand's choice (Choice 4: 100 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Saint Paul, MN - USA, Obsidian Towers's choice (Choice 4: 100 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Columbus, OH - USA, Columbus in Darkness's choice (Choice 4: 100 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Green Bay, WI - USA, Shattered Dreams's choice (Choice 4: 100 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Phoenix, AZ - USA, Unchained Arizona's choice (Choice 4: 100 XP), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 5: Option Choice 2: 140 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 5: Option Choice 3: 120 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 5: Option Choice 4: 100 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 5: Option Choice 5: 80 XP not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 5: Option Abstain not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 5: Vote by Twin Cities, MN, - USA, The Last Stand for option Choice 5: 80 XP not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 5: Vote by Twin Cities, MN, - USA, The Last Stand for option Choice 3: 120 XP not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 5: Vote by Twin Cities, MN, - USA, The Last Stand for option Choice 2: 140 XP not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 5: Vote by Columbus, OH - USA, Columbus in Darkness for option Choice 2: 140 XP not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 5: Vote by Columbus, OH - USA, Columbus in Darkness for option Choice 5: 80 XP not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 5: Vote by Green Bay, WI - USA, Shattered Dreams for option Choice 5: 80 XP not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
Chronicle/Position | Voted for | Comment |
---|---|---|
Marquette, MI - USA, Shattered Tears over Rural Michigan | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | Per staff |
Joinville, SC - Brazil, Danse Macabre | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | 60 xp is more them enough. |
Brasília, DF - Brazil, Caldas Novas | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Chicago, IL - USA, Prey to Predator | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Abstain | |
Twin Cities, MN, - USA, The Last Stand | 1st: Choice 4: 100 XP 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 2: 140 XP 5th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | Per player vote. |
Lisbon, Lisbon - Portugal, Eternal Cursed Darkness | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Minneapolis, MN - USA, Swift to Shed Blood | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 1: 160 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 5: 80 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Dubuque, IA - USA, Kingdom of Ashes | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) | |
New York City, NY - USA, Kings of New York | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Los Angeles, CA - USA, La Sangre De Los Angeles | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | While the argument that a game is able to regulate their starting EXP as they please, this does not stop the peer pressure for games to start with that EXP cap for players that are savvy enough to be able to make their character with another game, and then transfer to the game after a waiting period. In addition, the process of making a 60 point character for a brand new player is already overwhelming enough, let alone 160. |
Campinas, SP - Brazil, Império das Cinzas | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Rio Grande, RS - Brazil, Sobre a Areia Sempre Hostil | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Maldonado - Uruguay, Maldonado by Night: Magus et Artifex | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
São Paulo, SP - Brazil, São Paulo by Night | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 3: 120 XP 3rd: Choice 1: 160 XP 4th: Abstain | |
Rockland, NY - USA, Under The Rock | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Abstain | |
Saint Paul, MN - USA, Obsidian Towers | 1st: Choice 4: 100 XP 2nd: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 3rd: Choice 5: 80 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | Per STs and player discussion |
Mt. Dora, FL - USA, Mutual Alliance | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | Per staff discussion. The answer to XP bloat is not more XP. The costs of powers, abilities, attributes etc. did not change. The extended play of PC's seems to have caused a wide-spread panic that new sheets can't keep up. Under the original MET rules we are now throwing 20 months worth of XP at sheets to try and keep up. |
Mossoro, RN - Brazil, Mossoro by Night | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Curitiba, PR - Brazil, Curitiba By Night | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Abstain | As per staff. |
La Crosse, WI - USA, The Rivers Edge | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Stockton, CA - USA, Stockton by Night | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Abstain | |
Milwaukee, WI - USA, Nocturnal Rapture | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Peoria, IL - USA, The Shattered Mirror | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Decatur, IL - USA, The Chaos Within | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | STs do not need to give the full 160, just like they don't need to give the full 60. We are for this in letting new players get the bonus but also encourage STs to do what's best for their game. |
Tampa, FL - USA, Tampa Bay by Night | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Bartow, FL - USA, Polk County Prophecies | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Cleveland, OH - USA, An Uncertain Destiny | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Cedar Rapids, IA - USA, Five Nights | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | Where’s the option to reduce from 60? |
Sacramento, CA - USA, Sacramento By Night | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Duluth, MN - USA, Thicker than Blood | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Chicago, IL - USA, Dark Requiem | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Fredericksburg, VA - USA, Caine's Chosen: Liberty in Death | 1st: Choice 5: 80 XP 2nd: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Plainfield, IL - USA, Obsidian Shadows | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Norwalk, CT - USA, Rails of Revolution | 1st: Choice 5: 80 XP 2nd: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 3rd: Abstain | |
San Francisco, CA - USA, Always Comes Evening | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Abstain | |
Providence, RI - USA, Hidden Flame | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | We have already doubled the maximum starting XP, and then maximum monthly XP. If we do not put the brakes on this, we are heading towards an XP arms race sort of situation where there will never be "enough" starting XP. |
Griffin, GA - USA, Immortal Nights Theater | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Dayton, OH - USA, Dying Embers | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Orland Park, IL - USA, Enigmas of Rage | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Allentown, PA - USA, Steel Valley by Night | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | More xp only worsens the issue. Can we please stop with just throwing xp at the “problem” and actually address the root causes of the decade + old concern? |
Recife, PE - Brazil, Pernambuco by Night: Forever Haunted | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Madison, Wi - USA, Black Crusade | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Abstain | |
Lancaster, OH - USA, Never Ending Nights | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Columbus, OH - USA, Columbus in Darkness | 1st: Choice 3: 120 XP 2nd: Choice 4: 100 XP 3rd: Choice 2: 140 XP 4th: Choice 5: 80 XP 5th: Choice 1: 160 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Ouro Preto, MG - Brazil, Dying of the Light | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Portland, ME - USA, Blackened Veins | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Lexington, KY - USA, Panders Playground | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Abstain | This solves nothing and creates more escalation to provide a 'challenge' to 'sheets that are too large'. |
Alto Tietê, SP - Brazil, Sang Royal | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Vale do Paraíba, SP - Brazil, Vale Sangrento | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Kenosha, WI - USA, Memento Mori | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Boston, MA - USA, Reclaimed | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | I don't see a reason to gatekeep the 100xp from the fundraiser for future players and PCs. |
Los Angeles, CA - USA, Dark Side of the Moon | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Green Bay, WI - USA, Shattered Dreams | 1st: Choice 4: 100 XP 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 1: 160 XP 4th: Choice 2: 140 XP 5th: Choice 3: 120 XP 6th: Abstain | |
Columbus, OH - USA, Wyld Prophets | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Rohnert Park, CA - USA, Shadows Crossing | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 4: 100 XP 3rd: Choice 2: 140 XP 4th: Choice 1: 160 XP 5th: Choice 3: 120 XP 6th: Choice 5: 80 XP | Per player/staff vote |
Annapolis, MD - USA, Vitae Aeternus | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Bradenton, FL - USA, Chaos & Entropy | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Abstain | |
Londrina, PR - Brazil, Blood and Vendetta | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) | |
Phoenix, AZ - USA, Unchained Arizona | 1st: Choice 5: 80 XP 2nd: Choice 4: 100 XP 3rd: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Chicago, IL - USA, New Moon Rising | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 3rd: Choice 5: 80 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 3: 120 XP 6th: Choice 2: 140 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Hartford, CT - USA, Dark Colony | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Lancaster, OH - USA, Mountains Dark Heart | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | Per player vote. |
New Rochelle, NY - USA, Seasons of Strange | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Peoria, IL - USA, The Far Dawn | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | What Jesse from Bloomington, IL - Zephyr of Darkness said. This comment has been revised 1 time. Click here to see revision history Version 2 dated: Mar 19 2025, 5:45pm EDT What Jesse from Bloomington, IL - Zephyr of Darkness said. |
Bloomington, IL - USA, Zephyr of Darkness | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Abstain | People get way too hung up on XP. I'll almost always vote for more XP for people because I just don't really care how much XP people have. You either know how to run the sheet or you don't and the amount most of the time truly doesn't matter. I'd even support a prop that says PCs can have a maximum of X amount of XP. (Let's be real, it would have to be the size of the largest PC in the org plus at least a few hundred or we'd piss people off). Your ST can give you that XP as much or as little at a time as they want. But that's all you ever get. Now go tell stories and actually play instead of worrying about who has more XP than who. Everyone says they are here for story, then be here for story. Maybe just doing XP like that would be the way to go. You can have 2500 or whatever and your ST doles it out when they feel you've earned it. |
Bridgeport, CT - USA, Bridgeport by Night: The Broken City | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) | |
Baltimore, MD - USA, Dark Harbor | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Abstain | The problem of getting new sheets caught up is *not* the XP, it is the approvals for rarer/more powerful stuff. That said, I also don't think its right that we made a big deal about giving people 100 bonus xp with 6 months to spend it, only to just give that to everyone new as a baseline. |
Salvador, BA - Brazil, Veritas Salvatore | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Cincinnati, OH - USA, Rage and Fury | 1st: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 2nd: Choice 5: 80 XP 3rd: Choice 4: 100 XP 4th: Choice 3: 120 XP 5th: Choice 2: 140 XP 6th: Choice 1: 160 XP 7th: Abstain | |
Grady, GA - USA, Whispers of Grady | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Nova Uruguaiana, RS - Brazil, Uruguaiana By Night – Susurros de la Oscuridad | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
Cambridge, MA - USA, The Midnight Rose | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) | Per player feed back This comment has been revised 1 time. Click here to see revision history Version 1 dated: Mar 19 2025, 11:11am EDT We don't need to up xp. This doesn't solve any issues in the org reguarding it. We already have xp bloat for small pc. Version 2 dated: Mar 21 2025, 1:12pm EDT Per player feed back |
San Antonio, TX - USA, Libertatis Cunabula | 1st: Choice 1: 160 XP 2nd: Choice 2: 140 XP 3rd: Choice 3: 120 XP 4th: Choice 4: 100 XP 5th: Choice 5: 80 XP 6th: Choice 6: 60 XP (No Change) 7th: Abstain | |
AHC 1 | 1st: Abstain |
What Jessie from Bloomington, IL - Zephyr of Darkness said.