[Poll] Custom Content in Vampire Genres
Status message
Displaying output for ranked votingOpen Votes
Proposal Type: Opinion Poll
Opened: 15-Oct-2019 12:00AM EDT
Closing: 22-Oct-2019 12:00AM EDT
Please keep the following in mind when responding to this Poll:
These options apply only to Vampire genres. Discussions/opinions about Custom Content in all other genres within the org are not relevant to the poll.
Custom Content in the current context does not refer to OWbN canon, such as Justicarial Edicts and other aspects of Vampire genres that are specific to the org's continuing story.
This vote will be ranked, to give us a better idea of what the org at large would like to see happen with Vampire Custom Content in the future.
File / Document: No file attachments for this vote.
Ballot Options Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.
Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals.
Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged.
Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.
Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet.
Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres.
Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval.
51 out of 155 eligible voters cast their ballot
Results (using Instant Run-Off):
Event log for this vote:
Results (using Instant Run-Off):
- Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. (60.8%)
- Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval.
- Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.
- Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.
- Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet.
- Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals., Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres.
| Rounds | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | 11 | 11 | 12 | 0 |
| Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | 21 | 21 | 23 | 31 |
| Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. | 5 | 7 | 0 | 0 |
| Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. | 12 | 12 | 16 | 20 |
Event log for this vote:
- Round 1: Option "Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals." had zero votes for 1st choice and therefore is eliminated.
- Round 1: Option "Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres." had zero votes for 1st choice and therefore is eliminated.
- Round 1: Eliminated: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. (votes reallocated: 2)
- Milwaukee, WI - USA, Nocturnal Rapture's choice (Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Phoenix, AZ - USA, Unchained Arizona's choice (Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 2: Option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 2: Option Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 2: Option Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 2: Eliminated: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. (votes reallocated: 7)
- Los Angeles, CA - USA, La Sangre De Los Angeles's choice (Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Milwaukee, WI - USA, Nocturnal Rapture's choice (Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Sacramento, CA - USA, Sacramento By Night's choice (Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Columbus, OH - USA, Columbus in Darkness's choice (Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Rohnert Park, CA - USA, Shadows Crossing's choice (Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Springfield, OH - USA, Ohio Knights Sabbat's choice (Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Phoenix, AZ - USA, Unchained Arizona's choice (Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 3: Option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 3: Option Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 3: Option Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 3: Option Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 3: Vote by Los Angeles, CA - USA, La Sangre De Los Angeles for option Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 3: Vote by Rohnert Park, CA - USA, Shadows Crossing for option Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 3: Eliminated: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. (votes reallocated: 12)
- St. Louis, MO - USA, Shadows of St. Louis's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Mossoro, RN - Brazil, Mossoro by Night's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Stockton, CA - USA, Stockton by Night's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Peoria, IL - USA, The Shattered Mirror's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Decatur, IL - USA, The Chaos Within's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Boston, MA - USA, Reclaimed's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Rio de Janeiro, RJ - Brazil, City of Wonders's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Edwardsville, IL - USA, Caught in Eternal Twilight's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Phoenix, AZ - USA, Unchained Arizona's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Chicago, IL - USA, New Moon Rising's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Indianapolis, IN - USA, Past is Prologue's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Amador, CA - USA, Gaia’s Call's choice (Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres.), was just eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Option Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Option Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Option Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Option Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. not included because it was previously eliminated
- Round 4: Vote by St. Louis, MO - USA, Shadows of St. Louis for option Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by St. Louis, MO - USA, Shadows of St. Louis for option Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by St. Louis, MO - USA, Shadows of St. Louis for option Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Mossoro, RN - Brazil, Mossoro by Night for option Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Mossoro, RN - Brazil, Mossoro by Night for option Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Mossoro, RN - Brazil, Mossoro by Night for option Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Mossoro, RN - Brazil, Mossoro by Night for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Stockton, CA - USA, Stockton by Night for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Peoria, IL - USA, The Shattered Mirror for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Peoria, IL - USA, The Shattered Mirror for option Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Peoria, IL - USA, The Shattered Mirror for option Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Decatur, IL - USA, The Chaos Within for option Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Decatur, IL - USA, The Chaos Within for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Decatur, IL - USA, The Chaos Within for option Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Decatur, IL - USA, The Chaos Within for option Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Rio de Janeiro, RJ - Brazil, City of Wonders for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Edwardsville, IL - USA, Caught in Eternal Twilight for option Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Edwardsville, IL - USA, Caught in Eternal Twilight for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Phoenix, AZ - USA, Unchained Arizona for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Chicago, IL - USA, New Moon Rising for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Indianapolis, IN - USA, Past is Prologue for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
- Round 4: Vote by Amador, CA - USA, Gaia’s Call for option Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. not included because option was eliminated. Checking next preferred option for this voter.
| Chronicle/Position | Voted for | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Dubuque, IA - USA, Kingdom of Ashes | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| New York City, NY - USA, Kings of New York | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| St. Louis, MO - USA, Shadows of St. Louis | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Los Angeles, CA - USA, La Sangre De Los Angeles | 1st: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 2nd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| São Paulo, SP - Brazil, São Paulo by Night | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 7th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Mossoro, RN - Brazil, Mossoro by Night | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 7th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Iowa City, IA - USA, Fields of Rage | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Berkeley, CA - USA, Wasting the Dawn | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Stockton, CA - USA, Stockton by Night | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. | |
| Milwaukee, WI - USA, Nocturnal Rapture | 1st: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 4th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. | |
| Peoria, IL - USA, The Shattered Mirror | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Decatur, IL - USA, The Chaos Within | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 3rd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 7th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Tampa, FL - USA, Tampa Bay by Night | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Philadelphia, PA - USA, Honor in the Shadows | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Evansville, IN - USA, Paradise Lost | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Sacramento, CA - USA, Sacramento By Night | 1st: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Philadelphia, PA - USA, Nusquam | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Fredericksburg, VA - USA, Caine's Chosen: Liberty in Death | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. | |
| Auburn, CA - USA, Lux Tenebras | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 7th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. | |
| Norwalk, CT - USA, Rails of Revolution | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. | |
| San Francisco, CA - USA, Always Comes Evening | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. | Custom content is good. |
| Providence, RI - USA, Hidden Flame | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 7th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. | |
| Atlanta, GA - USA, Whispers of Atlanta | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 6th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. | |
| Allentown, PA - USA, Steel Valley by Night | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Columbus, OH - USA, Columbus in Darkness | 1st: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 2nd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. | |
| Portland, ME - USA, Blackened Veins | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 3rd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 4th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 5th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 6th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 7th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. | Per game consensus. |
| Lexington, KY - USA, Panders Playground | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. | |
| Vale do Paraíba, SP - Brazil, Vale Sangrento | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Washington, DC - USA, Shadows on the Mall | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Boston, MA - USA, Reclaimed | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 3rd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. | Upon reading this and working hard and thinking about it. I honestly think that Coordinator approval is the wrong place for most of this. Having been on multiple teams approving custom content for clan specifics just causes a headache. Custom content should just be a full vote and done with. |
| Rio de Janeiro, RJ - Brazil, City of Wonders | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. | |
| Green Bay, WI - USA, Shattered Dreams | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Gimli, MB - Canada, Sang Nordique | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| St. Augustine, FL - USA, On Haunted Ground | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | While I know that a lot of CC and Magic Items floating around the org are wonky, and I dont let check into my game, there is some that is unique and adds flavor and depth to characters. I would hate to squash that creativity with Org wide bans. But that is just me. |
| Rohnert Park, CA - USA, Shadows Crossing | 1st: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 2nd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 3rd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Northern Virginia, VA - USA, Night Falls | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | The current system works and the ST's have the right to allow it in their game or not. NVA feels we don't need to regulate this. |
| Annapolis, MD - USA, Vitae Aeternus | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Springfield, OH - USA, Ohio Knights Sabbat | 1st: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. | |
| Edwardsville, IL - USA, Caught in Eternal Twilight | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 3rd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 4th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 5th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 6th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 7th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. | I’ve seen well-written, balanced powers.
And then I’ve seen things like Fist of Judgement, Irish Exit, and Antarabhava, just to name a few.
Given the ridiculousness of Customs that Coords have already produced, it is clear that no single administrator can be trusted to approve balanced custom content.
This comment has been revised 1 time. Click here to see revision history Version 2 dated: Oct 21 2019, 9:42am EDT I’ve seen well-written, balanced powers. And then I’ve seen things like Fist of Judgement, Irish Exit, and Antarabhava, just to name a few. Given the ridiculousness of Customs that Coords have already produced, it is clear that no single administrator can be trusted to approve balanced custom content. |
| Phoenix, AZ - USA, Unchained Arizona | 1st: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 4th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 5th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. | |
| Chicago, IL - USA, New Moon Rising | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. | |
| Worcester County, MA - USA, Quabbin | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 5th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 6th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. | Regarding Option 7, which is our first choice: We would want the non-mechanical custom content to be Coordinator Notify, so that the Coordinator has the option to check and see whether everyone's idea of non-mechanical benefits remains similar. |
| Gainesville, FL - USA, Won't Back Down | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 3rd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 4th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 5th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 6th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 7th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. | |
| Indianapolis, IN - USA, Past is Prologue | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. | |
| New Rochelle, NY - USA, Seasons of Strange | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 3rd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Amador, CA - USA, Gaia’s Call | 1st: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 2nd: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 3rd: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 4th: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. | |
| Peoria, IL - USA, The Far Dawn | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 4th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 5th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. | There are no ideal choices. |
| Bloomington, IL - USA, Zephyr of Darkness | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | Sts should have the power to say yes and no in their own respective games. |
| Nashville, IN - USA, Tea With Dragons | 1st: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 5th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 7th: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. | |
| Bridgeport, CT - USA, Bridgeport by Night: The Broken City | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 3rd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 4th: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 5th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. | |
| Baltimore, MD - USA, Dark Harbor | 1st: Option 3: The current system for Custom Content in all Vampire genres remains unchanged. 2nd: Option 4: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval. 3rd: Option 5: All Custom Content in all Vampire genres is Coordinator approval and all items approved must added to the appropriate genre/clan packet. 4th: Option 7: Custom content in all Vampire genres that has no mechanical effect is Storyteller approval. Custom content in all Vampire genres that has a mechanical effect/benefit is Coordinator Approval. 5th: Option 1: All Custom Content is disallowed for use in all Vampire genres. 6th: Option 2: All Custom Content is disallowed in all Vampire genres, except for custom blood magic paths and rituals. 7th: Option 6: Create a board or position to oversee all Custom Content in all Vampire genres. |
I’ve seen well-written, balanced powers. And then I’ve seen things like Fist of Judgement, Irish Exit, and Antarabhava, just to name a few. Given the ridiculousness of Customs that Coords have already produced, it is clear that no single administrator can be trusted to approve balanced custom content.