[Administrative Proposal] Character Regulation Bylaw 13, The Red List, Revision and Formatting
Open Votes
This does not require a Second, but if you do not agree you may put Objection in the subject line to force this Proposal to go to a vote.====================================================================
I hereby propose the following changes to the Red List Bylaw for the following two reasons:
1. The original Proposal had information without actual reference points that fit within the Bylaws (for example, "13.A.i" was just floating without a reference # to identify it by except for the use of the title listed under A) which doesn't match the formatting of our Bylaws and leaves items in the Bylaws that have no reference items. It was originally proposed thusly, but is sloppy documentation and needs to be cleaned up.
The original vote was:
Vote: RedListProc2
Announced: Tue Jan 25 14:12:54 2005
Closed: Tue Feb 1 14:47:01 2005
Proposed by: Joe Sherrange (NVA)
Seconded by: Josh Strassman (DC)
Summary: Red List Procedures
2. Somewhere along the line, the last paragraph was cut off. It says:
"All rewards, Trophy or otherwise, for
the slaying of an Anathema will be determined by the appropriate Coordinator and"
Somehow it got cut off. The original vote had this line complete, and this proposal will restore it to its original sentence completion (marked with ***):
"All rewards, Trophy or otherwise, for the slaying of an Anathema will be determined by the appropriate Coordinator and ***the Camarilla Coordinator.***"
================
Current Bylaw:
13) Red List
A) Anathema
All Anathema shall be under the joint controlled of the Coordinator of the clan offering
Trophy and the Camarilla Coordinator. All Anathema named to the OWBN Red List shall require
the name to be put forward by the Clan Coordinator whose clan will offer Trophy, and must be
seconded by an additional Coordinator, either the Coordinator of the proposed Anathema (e.g.:
Clan Coordinator, Changing Breeds Coordinator, Sabbat Coordinator, etc) or the Camarilla
Coordinator. This is otherwise a Genre Proposal as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section
3.C.iii.
i) Reasons for Becoming an Anathema
Crimes against the Camarilla, as determined to be appropriate by the
Coordinator proposing the addition of the character to the Red List.
ii) PC Anathema
There are no PC Anathema. If the proposed Anathema is a PC, his or her
Storyteller must be consulted prior to the proposal. This does not give the Storyteller veto power
over the proposal, but the proposing Coordinator will note in the proposal the stance of the
Storyteller. This is otherwise a Genre Proposal as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section
3.C.iii.
B) Alastors
Alastors are a category of Archon, and therefore report to a specific clan. All Alastors
shall be under the joint controlled of the Clan Coordinator of the clan they report to and the
Camarilla Coordinator. The single exception to this rule is Lucinde, Ventrue Justicar. As such,
Lucinde is under the single control of the Ventrue Coordinator. Any other exceptions in the
future are subject to a Genre Proposal as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section 3.C.iii.
i) PC Alastors
There are no PC Alastors. If the proposed Alastor is a PC, his or her Storyteller
must be consulted prior to the proposal. This does not give the Storyteller veto power over the
proposal, but the proposing Coordinator will note in the proposal the stance of the Storyteller.
This is otherwise a Genre Proposal as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section 3.C.iii.
ii) Ways to be named to the rank of Alastors
Dedication to the Camarilla as determined to be appropriate by the Coordinator
proposing the addition of the character to the Alastors, or claiming to have slain an Anathema
(subject to in character
investigation prior to the proposal).
C) Appearance of Anathema and Alastors in Chronicles
The appearance of Anathema and Alastors are subject to two conditions, either that their
appearances are part of an ongoing plot as determined by the appropriate Coordinator and the
Camarilla Coordinator, or the appearance is a single instance unrelated to an ongoing plot. Both
instances require Genre Proposals as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section 3.C.iii., but in
the case of the ongoing plot, each specific instance need not be voted on separately, but must
be approved by the appropriate Coordinator and the Camarilla Coordinator after the plot
proposal has passed.
D) Trophy
The reward for slaying an Anathema is Trophy, which can include but is not limited to the
following:
Immunity to Bloodhunts (whether extant or future)
Breaking of a Blood Bond
Rite of Progeny
Boons
Monetary Rewards
Grant of Domain
Sanctioned Diablerie
Discipline Education
Indulgence (forgiveness for past transgressions)
Sanctioned Slaying (Rite of Destruction over an enemy, granted by the
appropriate Coordinator NPC)
Clan Friendship
The individual(s) claiming Trophy usually keeps the Anathema's possessions, as
well.
Characters slaying an Anathema may choose to give credit to an existing Alastor, in
which case they are not given Trophy (which includes not becoming an Alastor), though they
should be rewarded by the Alastor. These rewards are similar in nature to the Trophy rewards,
but are more limited by nature of the individual giving them. All rewards, Trophy or otherwise, for
the slaying of an Anathema will be determined by the appropriate Coordinator and
==================
Proposed Bylaw:
13. The Red List
A. Anathema
i. All Anathema shall be under the joint controlled of the Coordinator of the clan offering Trophy and the Camarilla Coordinator. All Anathema named to the OWBN Red List shall require the name to be put forward by the Clan Coordinator whose clan will offer Trophy, and must be seconded by an additional Coordinator, either the Coordinator of the proposed Anathema (e.g.: Clan Coordinator, Changing Breeds Coordinator, Sabbat Coordinator, etc) or the Camarilla Coordinator. This is otherwise a Genre Proposal as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section 3.C.iii.
ii. Reasons for Becoming an Anathema
1. Crimes against the Camarilla, as determined to be appropriate by the Coordinator proposing the addition of the character to the Red List.
iii. PC Anathema
1. There are no PC Anathema. If the proposed Anathema is a PC, his or her Storyteller must be consulted prior to the proposal. This does not give the Storyteller veto power over the proposal, but the proposing Coordinator will note in the proposal the stance of the Storyteller. This is otherwise a Genre Proposal as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section 3.C.iii.
B. Alastors
i. Alastors are a category of Archon, and therefore report to a specific clan. All Alastors shall be under the joint controlled of the Clan Coordinator of the clan they report to and the Camarilla Coordinator. The single exception to this rule is Lucinde, Ventrue Justicar. As such, Lucinde is under the single control of the Ventrue Coordinator. Any other exceptions in the future are subject to a Genre Proposal as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section 3.C.iii.
ii. PC Alastors
1. There are no PC Alastors. If the proposed Alastor is a PC, his or her Storyteller must be consulted prior to the proposal. This does not give the Storyteller veto power over the proposal, but the proposing Coordinator will note in the proposal the stance of the Storyteller. This is otherwise a Genre Proposal as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section 3.C.iii.
iii. Ways to be named to the rank of Alastors
1. Dedication to the Camarilla as determined to be appropriate by the Coordinator proposing the addition of the character to the Alastors, or claiming to have slain an Anathema (subject to in character investigation prior to the proposal).
C. Appearance of Anathema and Alastors in Chronicles
i. The appearance of Anathema and Alastors are subject to two conditions, either that their appearances are part of an ongoing plot as determined by the appropriate Coordinator and the Camarilla Coordinator, or the appearance is a single instance unrelated to an ongoing plot. Both instances require Genre Proposals as detailed in the Coordinators Bylaws section 3.C.iii., but in the case of the ongoing plot, each specific instance need not be voted on separately, but must be approved by the appropriate Coordinator and the Camarilla Coordinator after the plot proposal has passed.
D. Trophy
i. The reward for slaying an Anathema is Trophy, which can include but is not limited to the following:
1. Immunity to Bloodhunts (whether extant or future)
2. Breaking of a Blood Bond
3. Rite of Progeny
4. Boons
5. Monetary Rewards
6. Grant of Domain
7. Sanctioned Diablerie
8. Discipline Education
9. Indulgence (forgiveness for past transgressions)
10. Sanctioned Slaying (Rite of Destruction over an enemy, granted by the appropriate Coordinator NPC)
11. Clan Friendship
12. The individual(s) claiming Trophy usually keeps the Anathema's possessions, as well.
ii. Characters slaying an Anathema may choose to give credit to an existing Alastor, in which case they are not given Trophy (which includes not becoming an Alastor), though they should be rewarded by the Alastor. These rewards are similar in nature to the Trophy rewards, but are more limited by nature of the individual giving them. All rewards, Trophy or otherwise, for the slaying of an Anathema will be determined by the appropriate Coordinator and the Camarilla Coordinator.
Jenn Louise
OWbN Head Coordinator
"Of course I have (gone mad with power), have you ever tried going mad without power? Its boring, no one listens to you."